7. “Brick”
On paper, the concept of marrying hard boiled, stylized, Chandler-esque argot with a contemporary high school setting sounds dodgy at best. However, the debut by writer/director Rian Johnson works because of his dogged insistence to play it straight and let the audience find their way through the archaic dialogue to the mystery at the core. Brilliantly framed and photographed (not to mention captured on the cheap, with Johnson mostly shooting with one or two takes max throughout), and buoyed by fearless performances from his young cast, including a career page turner by Joseph Gordon-Levitt, “Brick” distinguishes itself as one of the most distinctive and original detective stories in years, and heralds the arrival of a major directorial talent.
6. “Half Nelson”
Thoughtfully shot and carefully observed, Ryan Fleck and Anna Boden’s undeniably assured character study of an improbable teacher-student friendship in urban, inner-city Brooklyn is a rare work of restraint and a remarkable debut feature film. Featuring an astonishing, Oscar-nominated performance by a then-twenty-six-year-old Ryan Gosling as a functioning drug addict, basketball coach and history educator, and an equally outstanding turn by newcomer Shareeka Epps as a street-wise middle-school student, the impressive indie drama is a considerate and mannered look at dynamics, race and make-shift families. Marked by an unsentimental, raw lens and a meditative ambient score (featuring instrumental tracks by orchestral rockers Broken Social Scene), Fleck and Boden take a familiar, potentially predictable relationship tale and imbue it with a politically-personal, starkly compelling, yet editorially neutral viewpoint that refuses to take any easy shortcuts.
5. “United 93”
As with any grieving process, Hollywood’s response to the terrible events of 9/11 was gradual — from removing the World Trade Center from the likes of “Zoolander” and “Spider-Man,” to the displaced anger of revenge movies like “Kill Bill” and “Man on Fire.” By the middle of the decade, even golden boy Steven Spielberg was using explicit 9/11 imagery in his tentpole “War of the Worlds,” and it seemed that the time had to come to address the day itself. And we couldn’t have asked for a better filmmaker than Paul Greengrass. Taking a measured, understated docu-drama approach was clearly the right one (particularly when placed against Oliver Stone’s ill-judged “World Trade Center”) — it paid true tribute to the heroes of United 93, while still enabling Greengrass to heighten the tension to almost unbearable levels (we vividly remember several people fleeing our screening while hyperventilating during its final sections).
4. “L’Enfant”
In 1988, Paul Schrader reimagined Robert Bresson‘s classic “Pickpocket” as a crime-drama centering on a narcissistic escort believing himself above the law. Conceptually, his “American Gigolo” works — the protagonist of “Pickpocket” too deems himself a “super human,” and egotism is ultimately his undoing — but where Schrader went wrong was mistaking Bresson’s automatism for emotional vacancy. Nearly two decades later, Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne took a stab at their own version of “Pickpocket” with the harrowing “L’Enfant,” a title referring to both the film’s nine-day-old child and the immature young father who sells him — a fatal error that condemns the man’s soul and sets him on a quest for spiritual salvation. There are principle differences in the Dardennes’ approach (long takes with hand-held cameras) and that of Bresson (a master of quick-cut editing), but when “L’Enfant” reaches its “moment of grace” — one strikingly similar to the one in “Pickpocket” — there’s no denying the comparison.
Half Nelson was implausible white guilt nonsense and one of the most overrated films i\’ve ever had to misfortune to see.
Can\’t believe you missed this one but with the torrent of great films from 2006, I guess it makes sense. Blame It On Fidel, an absolutely wonderful film about a French girl who must deal with her parent\’s activism during the 70\’s. There\’s so many good films here but this one definitely should at least have an honorable mention.
Seriously? The Fountain?
did you seriously just try to defend Superman Returns? No.
Crazy that all three Mexican auteurs could have been in the top ten here, although I thought Babel was a bit of a mess. Children Of Men and Pan\’s Labyrinth definitely belong here.
It\’s a downright travesty that "Clean" is not in your top ten here, let alone #1. That movie is top ten of all time for me. Absolutely perfect portrayal of a woman overcoming her own limitations and selfish nature. As beautiful, heartfelt and picturesque as any film out there.
Children of Men at No.1 for me by far.
The Fountain was a bloated infomercial on New Age with Hollywood\’s gold standard approval. Just the thought of it leaves me with a mouthful of sand and desperate for water. Spike Lee\’s Inside Man would be a nice replacement pick. Still haven\’t seen Old Joy. And the Proposition finally gives weight to any conversation of over taking Sam Peckinpah\’s The Wild Bunch as the best Western ever made.
I\’m really surprised \’Pan\’s Labyrinth,\’ \’The Departed\’ and \’Inland Empire\’ are not in the top 10. And how about \’Three Times\’? Glad to see love for \’Children of Men,\’ \’United 93,\’ \’Volver\’ and \’L\’Enfant.\’
juno star Olivia Thirlby was in UNITED 93
Yeah, tried to post my list as well, but was told it was too spammy. Indiewire, something you can fix there?
I agree. 2006 worst year of all the 2000s but then 2007 is the best year. Can\’t wait til the list tomorrow!
No mention of Little Miss Sunshine?
2006 was a bad year. The worst till 2012
I would post my list, but apparently my comment seems to be spammy.
Nah, it\’s great. I missed this the first time around when they ran it in 2009. It\’s a well-written interesting capsule in time (read the opening). I\’d be very curious to see how they feel about the order and line-up today and i suspect it would be fairly different.
Worst clickbait series ever… and during sundance at that! You can\’t even use the slow news day excuse.
Playlist will always consider it “alienating” but Fast Food Nation deserves a lot more love.