“Adaptation” (2002)
When some viewers claim they can’t stomach one Nicolas Cage performance, just how do you put out a movie with two of them? Well, back in 2002, Spike Jonze, hot off “Being John Malkovich,” his first collaboration with Charlie Kaufman, attempted just that. Based on Kaufman’s seemingly Kafka-esque endeavor to adapt Susan Orlean’s “The Orchid Thief,” “Adaptation” has Kaufman writing himself writing the script into the script. Did you get all that? In case that complicates things, Kaufman also creates a fictional twin brother, Donald Kaufman, whose dumbfounded idea for a thriller reaps the kind of success the glowering Charlie can only dream of. Now the kicker: Nicolas Cage plays both brothers. And you know what? It’s the kind of performance that few other actors could pull off. Though we know the actor is onscreen in both incarnations through technical trickery, Cage nevertheless makes us care for two disparate characters, nailing Charlie’s labored existential struggles and Donald’s mischievous, laidback existence. It may not be the best Cage performance, as he skews some of Kaufman’s more personal dialogue toward histrionics, but it’s definitely a keeper and bright spot in the dark ages of Cage’s 2000s oeuvre. It also lead to his second Oscar nomination for Best Actor. [B+]
“Raising Arizona” (1987)
It is not humanly possible to discuss the films of Nicolas Cage and not mention the 1987 Coen Brothers comedic masterpiece, “Raising Arizona,” which is akin to Robert De Niro’s “Raging Bull” or Marlon Brando’s “On The Waterfront” in its virtuosity and significance in the actor’s career. Cage plays H.I. McDonnough, a recidivist con trying to make a go of it at the straight life with his ex-cop wife (Holly Hunter), but things go awry when she cannot conceive, and they hatch an ill-conceived plan to steal a baby from a family that just had quintuplets and probably won’t notice one missing lil’ critter. While large credit is due to the gut-bustlingly funny Coen brothers dialogue — “Edwina’s insides were a rocky place where my seed could find no purchase” — there’s no doubt that Cage imbues every line with either the most nuanced subtlety or the most outrageously funny manic energy (the flick boasts perhaps the best exaggerated facial contortions of all time and Cage’s Woody Woodpecker-like hair is a comedic juggernaut unto itself). Ironically, the Coens and Cage butted heads throughout, and neither party enjoyed their experience. “Joel and Ethan have a very strong vision, and I’ve learned how difficult it is to accept another artist’s vision. They have an autocratic nature,” he said at the time and, of course, has never worked with them since. Regardless, it’s one of the funniest movies ever made, and Cage tour de force turn is a huge part of its success. [A+]
“Matchstick Men” (2003)
In Ridley Scott’s low-key crime drama, based on the Eric Garcia novel of the same name, Cage plays a nutty (what else) thief who is planning a long con with his partner (Sam Rockwell) while at the same time trying to start a relationship with his teenage daughter (an exceptionally good Alison Lohman). Unfortunately, this stylish little movie gets weighed down by an overly elaborate twist ending, but until then, the movie happily exists as an emotionally resonant genre piece. Cage never lets his penchant for show-off-y theatricality overshadow the interior complexity of the character, a man with a number of disorders who genuinely wants to see his life get back on track, and it’s this mentality that lends credence to the tired “one last job” conceit. And it’s because of Cage that the film’s final scenes pack such a surprisingly heartfelt punch. [B+]
“Snake Eyes” (1998)
From the film’s opening moments, a virtuoso “unbroken” shot that travels around an Atlantic City sports complex, Cage is turned all the way up to 11. And a half. But that’s okay. As a corrupt cop who is unwittingly brought into a conspiracy involving the assassination of the secretary of defense (at a boxing match, no less), he injects a “who cares” attitude into the whodunit. As it turns out, the first-scene exuberance is a precursor to a more somber and complicated performance, one in which the character’s inherent lack of morality is constantly at odds with his ability as a detective. An underrated, late-era Brian De Palma mini-masterpiece that was only marred by a last-minute decision to entirely remove a third-act action sequence set in a hurricane, it’s Cage at his mischievous best. For a movie called “Snake Eyes,” Cage positively slithers. [B+]
While I am biased because of my hatred for this man's career, I do still need to say that I disagree with most of these picks. From what I have seen, Cage has given two truly good performances in his career. Raising Arizona and Adaptation are phenomenal! But I believe this has very little to do with Cage himself. The Coen Brothers and Spike Jonze are just that good.
I love Nic Cage
Cage Love, now!
metacritic?
Cage is one of those guys that make meh movies totally watchable. I can't count the times i've watched the second half of Con Air when I've caught it on TV.
Great list.
"underrated Scorsese picture"
No, it's a bad Taxi Driver retread. Can't believe you don't slag this while you slag Herzog's masterpiece.
Definitely a Taxi Driver, retread, no question. But this writer saw it way after the fact and expected a disaster. Was pleasantly surprised at how decent it was.
I guess it's all relative to one's experience in relation to a picture.
There is nothing hotter than late 80s Nic Cage.
You left out his performance in THE WEATHER MAN.
we did, it's my fault.
Forget The Weather Man, where's The Family Man? It is an underrated movie and features a good performance by Cage. I watch it every Christmas. I'll also agree with the first poster who says Cage's only "great" performances are Raising Arizona and Adaptation but I'll also include his Oscar-winning role in Leaving Las Vegas. So there you go, three.
Oh, and kudos for including The Rock (not so much for Face Off and Con Air) because it really has aged pretty well. It along with Speed, Terminator 2, and Die Hard 3 are pretty much the best action movies of the 90s, and almost has me saying, "They don't make them like they used to."
Red Rock West wasn't bad. actually, looking at his imdb page, it's depressing going from his oldest movies to his latest. he has made a LOT of bad movies to counter all these wonderful movies you've listed here.
Moonstruck got a better rating than Adaptation and Leaving Las Vegas? What the fuck? You guys are fucking stupid, clearly.
I agree with Moonstruck…his bad accent makes it unwatchable in my opinion…