Saturday, May 10, 2025

Got a Tip?

‘The Defenders’: Marvel’s Netflix Game Hasn’t Improved [Review]

What is it about Marvel TV shows and their inability to tell halfway redeemable superhero stories that pale in comparison to even the most mediocre big screen counterparts? Marvel’s ABC series are abominable (the upcoming “Inhumans” looks like it’s about to be savaged by critics), the FX shows aren’t great (sorry, I don’t love “Legion,” though it’s definitely the best of the bunch so far) and the comic book studio’s Netflix shows are largely hit-and-miss, at best. Even when they’re adequate (the glowering “Daredevil,” the snippy “Jessica Jones”), there are qualities within —  soap opera-ish melodrama, tons of plotblocking — that are so hard to tolerate.

READ MORE: ‘The Defenders’ Trailer: The War For New York Is Here

Maybe the question should be: what’s up with superhero narratives on TV and their atrocious attention to quality control? And it’s not a question of budgets and VFX that can’t compare; they can’t, but strong characters and story should always trounce these issues.

Perhaps the Marvel TV problem is the lack of MCU mastermind Kevin Feige and the surplus of Jeph Loeb (and perhaps Ike Perlmutter, who now has no purview over Marvel movies but still has input on their small screen fare). Say what you will about Marvel Studios, but they are very good at what they do and generally nail the absolutely critical tone of their superhero movies. And they’re not unimpeachable. I haven’t liked a Marvel movie since ‘Civil War,’ but tone and consistency of brand is not something they need to worry about.

The-DefendersMarvel shows on Netflix suffer from a litany of issues. Plotting is rote, actors are an issue unless your name is Krysten Ritter (the less said about Mike Colter and Finn Jones the better), the angst-ridden characters are largely one-dimensional (everyone), their problems tend to be a wounded-bird variation on “what’s your damage?” and the tone is…well, fairly consistent, but it’s a superficially dark and moody mien that never convinces. It’s cheesy and hackneyed, to be honest, like watching a bunch of B-list actors who failed their audition to play Christian Bale’s Dark Knight thinking to themselves, “if I can just express a little bit more inner torment and anguish, I’m gonna nail this role.”

Apart from half a season of “Jessica Jones” (until it restarts itself all over again midway through the season with big plotblock 2×4 to the face), elements of “Daredevil” like Wilson Fisk (Vincent D’Onofrio) (please don’t insist on those poorly choreographed hallway fights; one long shot doesn’t inherently make that shot good), and the introduction of the Punisher, Marvel’s Netflix shows are largely unremarkable. Like the problem with many superhero narratives in movies and TV, they place a high premium on brooding aesthetics while offering very little in the way of persuasive emotional, psychological or moral depth (the gaslighting moments of “Jessica Jones” being the exception). Even classic good vs. evil archetypes (we’re not asking for a lot) aren’t very compelling.

Which takes us to “The Defenders,” Marvel’s latest show. The confluence of all the superhero shows that have come before plays more like “Luke Cage” and “Iron Fist” (the worst of the bunch) and less “Daredevil” and “Jessica Jones.” “The Defenders,” like all of the other Marvel Netflix shows, is a passive rather than engaging experience. It’s like a lot of TV, which is incredibly easy to digest but extremely difficult to gain nutrition from. It’s classic Television, before the age of engaging Peak TV: you can switch your brain off for a minute because there is virtually nothing to think about other than what’s on screen. No pesky subtext, none of that nuance stuff, no mystery other than where the plot will go, but even blockbuster escapism is far more interesting than what little is given here.

Diagnosing the issues of ‘Defenders’ is somewhat difficult because the show has zero to say other than the now-clichéd notion that there’s no I in team if you want to defeat the bad guys (the mother hen of which is Sigourney Weaver). This version says: reluctant, sort-of super heroic people can still be superheroes.

“The Defenders” is more plot follow through than anything else, essentially a continuation of the “Iron Fist” story that was weaved through “Daredevil.” That narrative focused  on the evil, mystical ninja force known as The Hand, which is trying to take over and destroy New York City (for reasons unknown, but surely feel weightless). If that sounds lame, that’s because it is.

The petulant and privileged Danny Rand (aka Iron Fist, and played by a perpetually huffy Jones) and Matt Murdock (aka Daredevil, and played by Cox who is no thespian) are trying to defeat The Hand in parallel, but unbeknownst to one another and not in conjunction. Sucked into their efforts is the unenthusiastic Jessica Jones (Ritter) — whose character is really just the annoyingly sarcastic and insufferable Daria of the super hero world—and more accidentally, Luke Cage (the still utterly wooden Mike Colter), the earnest and easily most blandly written character of the bunch. (Special shout out to Scott Glenn‘s particular brand of awful as the character Stick).

These disparate forces of good in New York —  not heroes, just regular Manhattanites with special abilities — unite to fight the forces of evil and it doesn’t get much deeper. What’s supposed to differentiate “The Defenders” is the idea that none of these characters are traditional superheroes, and most of them are incredibly averse to working with other people. So while a threat to New York lives below the city, the Defenders vote against their own best interests and try and work solo, rather than recognizing the strength in numbers. Until they don’t and they figure shit out. That’s pretty much the show.

There’s been some talk of “The Defenders” characters crossing over into the Marvel Cinematic Universe. For one, you can bet that’s never going to happen for political reasons (Feige hates Perlmutter and basically all the TV shows, and for good reason, as they cheapen the Marvel Studios brand) and two, quality control. These shows simply aren’t up to par. So you can cross that pipe dream off your list.

The-Defenders-Around-the-Table

While only four of eight episodes of “The Defenders” were made available to press (the show is truncated compared to the thirteen episodes of the previous shows), nothing about the series sparks or catches fire. Even the fourth episode that finally teams up all characters is underwhelming.

With lackluster characters (and flavorless actors) picking up where their facile story left off, “The Defenders” doesn’t offer much to viewers. Mind you, fans of superhero TV shows will probably leave feeling satisfied. It’s standard, digestible, easy-to-following storytelling that is at least marginally entertaining. And truth be told, “The Defenders” is moderately watchable, but it’s just not any good. [C]

About The Author

Related Articles

15 COMMENTS

    • or it reads as criticism (echoed by many) and you are defensive. I haven’t been able to make it through a season of any Marvel show (excluding Legion) because they are all terrible.

    • This reads like an overly defensive nerd who brags in real life about being Loyal to Corporate Brands found out somebody else doesn’t like their nerd shit

  1. >like watching a bunch of B-list actors who failed their audition to play Christian Bale’s Dark Knight thinking to themselves, “if I can just express a little bit more inner torment and anguish, I’m gonna nail this role.”

    That seems a little harsh, but I’ll admit it made me smile.

  2. I dunno,the first half of Season 2 of Daredevil was amazing,very entertaining,and I enjoyed the first half of Luke Cage too,Iron Fist was unwatchable though.

  3. Dear Reviewer,

    you sound just like any other online reviewer nowadays: hating on anything and everything. I dunno who the hell, keeps giving people like you jobs to review shit. Might as well, type in “It’s bad, I hate it” and spare everyone their 10 minutes of reading through your angry tirade of how Marvel shows are not exactly how you envision them to be.

    As for everyone else, who found their voice on the internet to spread their hate, because that’s the only thing they got going in their miserable lives: Just stop already.

    Cordially,

    A reader.

    • Did you watch The Defenders? It was deplorable. I agree, most people online these days are just spreading hate; However, this program was just the pits. I’m so glad Netflix started with Daredevil first, because each successive program afterwards just went straight downhill.

      • Your opinion == truth. That’s what all of you people don’t seem to get. You’re trying to convince everyone so hard how bad a show or movie is. We get it, you didn’t like it. Move the fuck on.

  4. Gotta agree a bit about Iron Fist. And must also agree – what is up with Glenn’s portrayal of Stick ? Glenn has always seemed to be a card carrying member of the “To the Wooden Manner Born” club, but his slack jawed slightly retarded approach to this character is really weird sometimes. He needs some coaching.
    Defenders – we shall see

    • WATCH MOVIES (hd)-2017
      Hello, all ??? I will provide info Would you like to watch this movie in 2017? You can start here. ALLMOVIESHD12.BLOGSPOT.COM
      That’s where I started it

  5. I’ve been enjoying AGENTS of SHIELD far more than any Marvel movie for a number of years now. This reviewer must love it too as it’s the only show he doesn’t hate on in the above article. In fact, he doesn’t even mention it. Bizzare.

  6. “These disparate forces of good in New York —  not heroes, just regular Manhattanites with special abilities — unite to fight the forces of evil and it doesn’t get much deeper.”

    LMAO WHAT?! it’s MARVEL bro!! It’s superheroes vs. villains!! How much deeper is it supposed to get???

    “…and the tone is…well, fairly consistent, but it’s a superficially dark and moody mien that never convinces.”

    Newsflash: it’s all set in NEW YORK! Not exactly the happiest place on Earth. The tone is consistently accurate if nothing else

    I could go on and on, but I’ll sum it up by saying this: it’s 2017. Everything’s been done. Everything’s borrowed, everything’s stolen, nothing’s original. And when you’re dealing with a superhero show or movie what more do you want out of a story? Defenders could have done a LOT better with the plot, but the show was far from trash. Nowhere near it. This hate spree you went on was nothing short of laughable lol

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img
Stay Connected
0FansLike
19,300FollowersFollow
7,169FollowersFollow
0SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Articles