While the mechanics of Christopher Nolan‘s films can be divisive, there’s no denying that he’s is one of the best at enacting spectacle on the big screen —his achievements as such include the docking sequence in his most recent "Interstellar" to the sleight-of-hand in "The Prestige" to the tilted hallway fight of the mind-bending "Inception." During a talk last night at the Tribeca Film Festival hosted by Bennett Miller, Nolan was asked to choose which of his blockbuster sequences was his favorite. And he selected the pretty terrific opening airplane kidnapping scene from "The Dark Knight Rises."
“It took us about two days in Scotland," he explained about the sequence, which you can watch below. "And it was an incredible sort of coming together of months and months of planning by a lot of different members of the team who worked for months rehearsing these parachute jumps and wind walking, all these different things… The visual effects work in the sequence is very minimal… I was really amazed by what the team we had put together had achieved using very sort of old-fashioned methods, in a way. I was very proud of the way that came together.”
If there’s something clinical in Nolan’s answer, it shouldn’t be surprising given how he describes his screenwriting process. “I don’t write a story outline. I work intuitively, but I draw a lot of diagrams when I work," he said. "I do a lot of thinking about etchings by Escher, for instance. That frees me, finding a mathematical model or a scientific model. I’ll draw pictures and diagrams that illustrate the movement or the rhythm that I’m after.”
And that spirit carries over into the editing process: “I’ve always edited in a huge hurry," he said, "trying to catch that lightning in a bottle, just so the energy is there. I always think of editing as instinctive or impressionist. Not to think too much, in a way, and feel it more.”
Yet Nolan is still operating in a very mainstream business, one that requires success of the four quadrant variety —which Nolan attributes to an "enormous amount of luck"— to be afforded the kind of creative latitude he enjoys. It’s a process that requires dealing with studios too, but Nolan has figured out how to deal with execuitves from one of his earliest supporters. “I learned how to accept notes from the studio while still pursuing your own vision from Steven Soderbergh, my mentor. You have to get out there and find a place for yourself. You have to make your own rules. You have to figure out what’s going to work for you… He taught me that you’re on your own and you have to get out there and make it work.”
Indeed, Nolan has been making it work quite well, but game recognizes game, and the director tipped his hat to one 2014 movie in particular. “I really loved ‘Whiplash‘ last year. I thought that was an incredible piece of work. That was the kind of film where when you see it, it’s very precisely put together and you’re very jealous,” he said.
Of course, the Q&A at Tribeca included the inevitable question about the ending of "Inception," but Miller fielded that one. “I asked him that same question backstage, and he said the answer is not for public consumption,” he said. But Nolan shared the advice his brother Jonathan gave him about keeping the ending secret: “Nobody will be able to look past what you’ve said.” [via Long Live Cinema/Tribeca].
Note: audio is silent for the first 15 seconds or so, then kicks in.
In this moment, I am euphoric. Not because of some big guy\’s blessing, but because I am enlightened by my own masterpiece.
Calm down, Nolan. Now is not the time for praise. That comes later.
Eh. It was okay but not amazing.
FOR YOU
He was trying to grab your prize. -The Masketta Man
If I took off this scene, would he die?
It was CIA\’s birthday yesterday! A bit late, but happy birthday, big guy!
Nolan\’s a big director for me, and I don\’t care if people think I\’m just a hired gun shilling for this movie.
UUUU
BRAVO
R
A
V
O
…
Mosquito Man
Did he ever think of the consequences of crashing a plane…with NO SURVIVORS?!
BRAVO NOLAN
R
A
V
O
N
O
L
A
N
NAVO
Calm down Kevin! Now is not the time for lauding; that comes later.
Uh, you don\’t get to bring friends.
Let\’s not stand on ceremony Mr. Nolan
Agree
hey everybody join our secret club at play()pokemonshowdown()com/showderp
can somebody tell me what an md1ck is
Was liking this scene part of your plan?
Bane?
You\’re a big guy.
Nolan does it again!
You will
If I post in here, will you die?
…..Sir?
For you
Flying status = not so good
Who is CIA really?
littlefinger got owned
I think I must be the only one that doesn\’t like this scene.
Why would somebody shoot a scene, before throwing it out on a blog?
It was CIA\’s birthday yesterday! A bit late, but happy birthday, big guy!
If I post in here, will you die?
It was CIA’s birthday yesterday! A bit late, but happy birthday, big guy!
If I post in here, will you die?
Was breaking reality part of your plan?
He wasn\’t alone
Was writing click bait part of your plan?
4 u
I\’m sure a lot of Nolan fan boys will be a little hot headed after this revelation that this scene is his favorite. I say get those hot heads outta here.
GET OUTTA TOWN!
Lot of loyalty for a hired director.
They\’re expecting one of us in the wreckage, brother!
B R A V O N O L A N
R
A
V
O
N
O
L
A
N
Still irks me that they altered Bane\’s original voice. He sounded much more calm and intimidating in the IMAX Prologue compared to the loud and somewhat campy voice in the final version.
Brilliant sequence. Very well realised. But man, i can\’t get enough of the docking scene in Interstellar. just wow!
Very cool that Steven Soderbergh is his mentor. It\’s great how he took that advice, and has made it work so well for him.
LOTTA LOYALTY FOR A HIRED REPORTER
I\’m a big rising fire.
The one time I saw Chris Nolan was, I shit you not, in the basement at a USC frat party, completely gone on Ecstasy, and being railed by Dan "the fat guy from better off dead" Schneider
It would be extremely painful….
4u
If I take off that mask, will you die?
HE
UUUU
⠀
I have a lotta loyalty for a big guy. BRAVO NOLAN.
This can\’t be happening! I\’m in charge here!
THIS ARTICLE WAS BRED FOR ONE PURPOSE….FOR MEMES
IF I WATCH YOUR MOVIES, WILL YOU DIE?
Am I the only one who thinks this movie would have improved if Bane was black?
Tell me, do you bleed?
For you.
Chris Nolan is a fascinating director, during the filming of Interstellar we all wondered why my character was supposed to take a fat ogre shit in her spacesuit, but he kept saying it was part of the vision.
JUST
Zzzzzzon\’t worryzzzzzzz, no zzzzzchargezzzzz for zzzzzzzem.
For you maybe
for you
This can\’t be happening
"I don’t write a story outline. I work intuitively, but I draw a lot of diagrams when I work,"
OHH IT SHOWS NOLAN, IT SHOWS
LOOKS LIKE MEME BACK ON THE MENU BOYS
A LOTTA LOYALTY FOR A HIRED GUN!
Lotta loyalty for a hired writer
For you
The File I list with indiewire lists me, my men, Mr. Nolanhere and only ONE Interview!
Bane??
THEY WORK FOR THE MERCENARY. THE MASKETTA MAN???
You\’re a big guy
He doesn\’t fly so good.
Did we start the fire?
This is a great article, mind if I call it in to the agency?
Nobody cared who he was until he directed TDKR.
No one cared who I was till I put on the mask.
uuuu
There he is. There he goes again. Look, everyone! He posted it once again! Isn\’t he just the funniest guy around?! Oh my God.
Christopher Nolan is a true auteur. A master of his craft. And he was a good friend.
Nolan is quite the big guy.
This scene is a big guy for me, and taking over my brain must have been a part of it\’s plan. Of course, Bravo Nolan you\’re a real human being and a true detective. I don\’t know what to do anymore. I wake up in the middle of the night and immediately yell FOR YOU! I just can\’t help it.Even if it\’s just the faintest sound of the plane. Oh my God. Please save me. Somebody. I can\’t take it. My life is crashing with no survivors.
It was extremely painful
UUUU
LOOKS LIKE MEME BACK ON THE MENU BOYS
UUUU
BIG WHITE GUYS
NOOOO THIS CAN\’T BE HAPPENING! I\’M IN CHARGE HERE!
NOTHING! I SAID NOTHING!
What did Dr. Pavel tell them anyway?
Bravo, Nolan
>execuitves
I hate Nolan\’s editing. It\’s awesome the first time, but there\’s no re-watchability with his films. It\’s terrible compared to something like George Miller\’s editing
TELL ME ABOUT NOLAN, WHY DOES HE LIKE THIS SCENE?
By you, For you
What\’s the next step in Nolan\’s career?
This is my favourite scene from Nolan\’s masterpiece as well. No surprise there, as my loyalty is unparalleled.
So,was this a big moment in your career
For you?
Look at me. Look at me. I\’m the big guy now.
Ur a big guy
Did he get to bring friends ?
At least you can blog. Who are you?
I think Nolan does share our view and enthusiasm for this film.
TARS, set memeposting to 90%
I remember when I only 9. I had a huge thing for Nolan movies and prayed to him every night before bed, thanking for those masterpieces. He had my love, and he was my life back then. One day dad heard me and used bad words for homosexual. I was insulted, and called him a bad man. He slapped me and sent me back to sleep. I remember crying so much that night. It was so cold. Then I felt it; a sudden, welcome warmth coming towards me. Then I realized it was Chris; I was overjoyed. He whispered in my ear, "this is my plan". I knew what was coming, and I was ready. My posterior spreading wide, all of it for Nolan. It hurt so much, but it was like a Nolan masterpiece. Then out of nowhere, dad comes in. I vividly remember the cold stare, and his raspy voice saying "you\’re a big guy now". Nolan left through my window. Nolan is love, Nolan is life.
Bane?
Now\’s not the time for celebrating, that comes later.
On behalf of all of us here at the CIA,
Thank you Christopher for this big achievement and extreme leap forward in film-making. I, as many others, encourage you to continue your life-long career as a director in order to show all of us what art is. Life is like the smoke of a rising fire, it makes its way to the sky and continue to rise even after the embers of life have burned out. Again, it comes with great congratulations on your becoming a fine, word-class director. Now what\’s the next step of your master plan?
No one cared who I was until I put on the mask.
He didn\’t fly so good!
The flight plan I\’ve just been filed listed Nolan, I think he was the only one of them
Alright, get them on blog. I\’ll type it in.
U
U U
U
Where am I? I\’m so lost. Someone get me out of here!
First one to blog, get\’s to stay on my website.
Crashing this blog
WITH NO SHURVIVORS
Are we really sure that Bane is a big guy? I\’ve seen a lot bigger to be honest.
at least you can talk
A good scene, FOR YOU
so i told chris to make the opening line of his final batman movie "dr. pavel i\’m cia".. and he actually did it the absolute madman hahahahahahaha!
I love this scene but i always wondered, was Bane a big guy for the CIA man or was it originally based on the pain that Bane would feel if the CIA man would pull of the mask?
If he couldn\’t pull of this scene, would the film have died
Perhaps he\’s wondering why someone would shoot in IMAX, if you have to dub the voices?
Hey Chris, I was just wondering if you\’re planning on doing a sequel to Interstellar. I could work as your lead, or even at a smaller part. I know I,ve called you 7 times already, maybe your phone is broken or something. Please reply to this message. I could use some work y\’know
I\’ll show you who\’s boss of this plane.
Well congratulations! So what\’s the next part of your master direction?
we need one of us in the wreckage!
Was getting interviewed part of your plan ?
Lot of loyalty for a hired writer!
It was a big moment in his career.
As a pilot, there\’s nothing I love more than to see massive planes take flight on the big screen. Sometimes when I\’m traveling great distances over lakes and mountains I can\’t believe that I\’m the guy that\’s in control. I scream in my head "This can\’t be happening", but then I think back to this great scene and it fills me with hope. The hot feeling of worry in my head vanishes and it\’s replaced with the words "I\’m in charge here!" Thank you Mr Nolan for this fantastic film. If I ever meet you in person you can ride by plane for free, no charge for you.
Bravo Nolan!
Nolan is the biggest poster I\’ve ever seen, the biggest anyone\’s seen since the silent era
INCREASE THE FIRE
This can\’t be happening! I\’m in charge here!
Nolan, I\’m CIA
DUDE PLANES LMAO
Did you know CIA is taller than Bane?
My favorite part of this scene was when the plane crashed
This was a big scene for me!
Somebody get this hothead outta here!
Of course this is his favorite scene. Stay big.
I love this scene too! I\’d love to work with Chris Nolan, I could use some work
To be honest that scene didn\’t fly so well with me…
NOOOO THIS CAN\’T BE HAPPENING! I\’M IN CHARGE HERE!
NOTHING! I SAID NOTHING!
At least you can blog. Who are you?
He didn\’t fly so good!
Alright, get them on blog. I\’ll type it in.
U
U U
U
First one to blog, get\’s to stay on my website.
I love this scene but i always wondered, was Bane a big guy for the CIA man or was it originally based on the pain that Bane would feel if the CIA man would pull of the mask?
Perhaps he\’s wondering why someone would shoot in IMAX, if you have to dub the voices?
NOOOO THIS CAN’T BE HAPPENING! I’M IN CHARGE HERE!
NOTHING! I SAID NOTHING!
I love this scene but i always wondered, was Bane a big guy for the CIA man or was it originally based on the pain that Bane would feel if the CIA man would pull of the mask?
It looks like it would be extremely painful
Jesus christ literally this scene is literally cancer. This film is literally the shoah
Bane is big guy.
Poetry
Of courshe
The Fire Rises
of coursh that\’s his favorite
I love memes.
First one to talk gets to stay in my aircraft
NOLAN FOR BIG GUY CONFIRMED
Has it started?
He works for the mercenary
Uh, you don\’t get to bring friends.
Nothing, I said nothing!
They were trying to grab your prize.
Perfection.
For you
Have we started a fire?
No, brother! They expect one of us in the comment section.
You\’re a Big Guy!
For you
HAHAHA
This scene is responsible for the deaths of 150 hotheads.
BRAVO NOLAN
@Pike where\’s that DWP guy?
Response to hothead Pike
Or perhaps he\’s wondering why someone would shoot a scene before throwing it out of an editing.
Was getting caught part of your plan?
Aye.
aye
Prize was grabbed.
DOCTOR PAVEL I\’M CIA
LOTTA LOYALTY FOR A HIRED DIRECTOR!
Pike, do you feel in charge ?
i\’m afraid your cranial temperature is too high.
It\’s the biggest scene he\’s ever done. The biggest since the silent era.
Wow, I understand you\’d be proud of actually putting this thing together in a practical sense, but cinematically this one might just be Nolan\’s worst action sequence. Narratively, it is just utterly nonsensical. It doesn\’t make sense as you are watching it, and neither does it after alot of Nolanesque explaning in dialogue later on in the movie. I also just can\’t get over the fact that Bane and the doctor on the rope as the plane fuselage drops from around them, are hanging absolutely still. He was never a particularly good editor.
The chase sequence in The Dark Knight is better on all levels.
BANE?
ᕦ ( ͡°╭͜ʖ╮͡° )ᕤ
CRASHING THIS PLANE…
Interesting. I always thought this particular scene was one of Nolan\’s most spectacular pieces of large scale filmmaking. The way he moves the camera, frames the shots, edits the shots and uses Zummer\’s nightmarish music is riveting. It\’s a truly terrifying idea of an action scene and it sets the tone for the finale perfectly. The fire rises! Keep them coming, Christopher.
He has a lotta loyalty for a hired director!
BRAVO NOLAN
This was a big scene
Yes! The fire rises!
Tell me about Bane, why does he wear the mask?
You\’re a Big Guy!
For you
HAHAHA
aye
aye