In late 2003, this writer and another friend spent a few weeks doing some old-school serious reporting and digging to write a feature on the death of L.A. indie-songwriter Elliott Smith. Half the work isn’t even represented here, but countless interviews were conducted (over a dozen), several sources were tracked down and some things said on the record were so controversial they had to be cut (we also broke the news of his final album along with several other key pieces in this story).
Ex-girlfriends can testify to the fact that we were immersed in this subject and material. We lived-and-breathed this feature for longer than they would have liked (it was some fine, old school journalism if I do say so myself; we almost became involved in a book about Smith, but that’s another story…).
Thousands of people were obviously affected by his music and his death, which was never conclusively ruled as a suicide and subsequently left the door open to copious speculation and whispers of foul play (none that were ever really proven during the investigation). So we shouldn’t be surprised to hear news (via 24 bit) of a documentary titled, “Searching For Elliott Smith”
Immediately after Smith died, it was easy to get friends and family to speak on the record, but when the controversy started around his death, it wasn’t always so easy (though Smith photographer and friend Autumn de Wilde scored several key interviews for her excellent 2007 photobook).
But time has passed, and filmmaker Gil Reyes’ has scored some decent names to talk in his documentary, including friend and folksinger Mary Lou Lord, director Gus Van Sant (who brought his music to the mainstream with “Goodwill Hunting”) producer and confidante Larry Crane, Heatmiser bandmate Tony Lash, and Smith’s friend and musician Sean Croghan.
Perhaps most controversial is an interview with Jennifer Chiba, the girlfriend that was in the apartment when Elliott died (and was subsequently hit with a lot of nastiness and death rumors when the suicide ruling couldn’t be 100% confirmed). Other notable figures interviewed are director of the short Smith documentary “Strange Parallel,” Steve Hanft and David McConnell who helped record much of Smith’s last album From A Basement On The Hill (we also sp0ke with him back in the day).
Noticeably absent are key people like Quasi members Janet Weiss, Joanna Bolme (an ex-Smith girlfriend who joined this Portland band later) and Sam Coomes (a close friend of Elliott’s who seemingly never spoke on the record about Smith’s death until de Wilde’s aforementioned 2007 book; journos who followed this story closely considered him the holy grail in the picture even though he wasn’t apart of the last few years of his life).
Evidently there’s no trailer for the film yet, but the doc did have its premiere just a month ago (October 23, 2009) at the CMJ Music & Film Festival in New York City. There’s a blog for the film, a Facebook page, and an official site, but it seems to still be doing the small festival route.
Here’s the official synopsis, but the claims that his peers granted no interviews is overstated; we spoke to several of these aforementioned people (on-camera, yes).
Elliott Smith’s intensely intimate songs helped popularize lo-fi, indie-rock: A traditionally underground genre until Smith’s mainstream effort “Miss Misery” took Hollywood by surprise. But even after an Oscar nomination for Best Original Song, he managed to fly mostly under the radar. And Smith wanted it that way. After his suicide in 2003, Smith’s peers avoided the media. Granting very few print interviews and NO on-camera interviews. Until now. From his high school days as a National Merit Scholar, to his early work in the Portland rock band, ‘Heatmiser’, to critical acclaim… to his mysterious death at the age of 34. We learn the dark motivations behind a musical genius. And discover how psychic pain can also produce timeless art.
Thankfully it doesn’t sound like an investigation into his death, because that would likely be a fool’s errand (and certainly would provoke the ire of fans, family, peers, etc.). We’d be curious to see this, but we guess we missed our recent NY window. Maybe something like this will play Sundance or Slamdance?
Elliott’s music was obviously used all over Gus Van Sant’s “Goodwill Hunting” in 1997 (and then again in “Paranoid Park” in 2007), but the more interesting story is that Smith recorded some songs for Mike Mills’ “Thumbsucker” shortly before he died — and the indie singer was actually supposed to record many famous covers for the soundtrack before he died, John Lennon, Neil Young, etc., we wrote that story too — but unfortunately he passed away before it happened. His pre-existing cover of Big Star’s “13” however, was used in the film and Smith was able to pull off a cover of Cat Stevens’ “Trouble” before he died which was also featured in the picture.
"Able to pull off"? Really?
don't think you understand the context there dude or are reading into that.
Smith was still in recovery at the time. Mills said his work was slow and his work on the project intermittent.
Of course he can competently cover a Cat Stevens song. If that's what you're complaining about.
Was Jon Brion involved in the doc? I know he and Smith worked quite closely together.
No Brion. Would like to hear the about half a dozen or more version of Basement Under The Hill tracks that were recorded (though pieces made that album — McConnell told me back in the day that album was severely frankensteined after his death, drums from this session, guitar from here, etc.)
Brion basically called out Smith on his drug problems during a session and that destroyed their relationship right there and then. Smith actually even threatened to destroy the master tapes of their recordings.
There are a lot of unreleased recordings floating around the web that paint a greater picture of what Smith was up to in those final sessions. 'Basement on a Hill' as it was released is in my opinion a poor compilation of that period and doesn't reflect that the intended album was.
Definitely a compromised effort. The family wanted two ppl who didn't work on the record (Bolme, Schnapf) to put it together cause they felt comfortable with those two, meanwhile ppl like McConnell, one of the last ppl to record with him — though so was Fritz Michaud and Smith did recordings on his own too — were shut out, therefore the intentions were unknown.
Brion's holy grail from those sessions, True Love Is A Rose — a track McConnell told me he wished came out on Basement From A Hill — came out last year, so i wonder what recordings anon is talking about. I guess I stopped following about a year or two ago, so more tracks might have leaked.
I'd love to hear just Brion's version of the records, but not sure that's possible anymore.
Things were even clearly labelled when Schnapf and Bolme put that together.
in fact, that 'Ostritches' instrumental track on the album is actually something McConnell recorded himself and because they didn't ask, they put it on the album thinking it was a whimsical little thing Elliott put together.
When you are saying: "several sources were tracked down and some things said on the record were so controversial they had to be cut" you are obviously arising my curiosity.
I don't know if you can elaborate or not.
Even though 6 years have passed, his death is still an open case and there is still an homicide detective in charge.
nothing of that nature. nothing to do with his death. i prolly shouldn't have thrown that tease in there. It's in the aforementioned piece, it's all there, we just had to paraphrase a few times rather than let the person speak for themselves in quotes.
Thanks for clarifying.
I read reviews of this documentary and they are unequal, but some are really criticizing the fact that it was a vehicle for the vindication of Jennifer Chiba.
CORRECTION on your "overstatement" theory.
"Searching for Elliott Smith" DOES contain the first posthumous interviews with Smith's peers that are released to the general public. There may be other posthumous, on cam interviews out there(including yours), but I think Reyes' are the first to be seen by movie audiences (first in NY, then in Argentina). Please correct me if I'm wrong. Thanks.
I remember hearing some of the Jon Brion/Elliott tracks on the Largo PA on 2/14/01 after Jon and Elliott played that night. It makes me beyond sad to think that might be the one and only time I ever hear those songs. (Really glad to hear Mary Lou is involved in the project. She's great.)
I saw the film at CMJ, here's my review, which has been circled around many other sites and was up on the Sweet Adeline message board as well.
Thanks, Georgia
http://microphonememoryemotion.wordpress.com/2009/10/26/searching-for-elliott-smith-should-actually-be-called-the-vindication-of-jennifer-chiba/